More thoughts on this one later — expect to write variations on this theme — but putting it up here now as reference for future comment….
(Cross-posted to Sad Puppies 4 – will update with the link this afternoon)
The List is done. It’s not all on this page because there’s too much – the full list is viewable here.
My methodology was pretty basic – any comments that were favorable to the work got counted as a +1 and added to the tally. -1 comments or disagreement weren’t counted. I’ve probably been more generous on that front than others, because I included things like “I wish that was eligible” as a +1. A few clearly misplaced votes got moved to the appropriate place. If someone was the only person to suggest their own work, it’s been noted as a self-nomination – which, of course, is not against any rules. If other people voted, the self-nomination didn’t get listed. Works that have questions about whether they were eligible are noted in the full list.
View original post 1,245 more words